What is Personal Jurisdiction?
Personal jurisdiction regards the authority for a court to exercise jurisdiction over an individual. How to establish personal jurisdiction is discussed below.
Why is Personal Jurisdiction Required?
A court must have both subject-matter jurisdiction and personal jurisdiction in every case. While subject-matter jurisdiction regards the court’s authority to hear a certain type of case, personal jurisdiction regards the authority for a court to exercise jurisdiction over an individual.
That is, the court must have the legal authority to adjudicate the matter involving the specific individual.
Determining whether a court has personal jurisdiction over an individual is different for criminal and civil cases.
Personal Jurisdiction over Criminal Cases?
In a criminal case, a court has personal jurisdiction over the defendant if the defendant committed the alleged criminal conduct within the court’s geographic jurisdiction.
A federal court will have personal jurisdiction over a defendant committing any criminal activity within the United States, though the specific district in which to prosecute the case is specified by Rule 18 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure.
A state court will have personal jurisdiction over a defendant committing any criminal activity within that state’s borders.
There is a basis for a state court to exercise personal jurisdiction over a defendant who committed a criminal act outside of the state if there is a detrimental impact on the state.
- Relevant Law: Strassheim v Daily, 221 US 280, 285; (1911), Justice Oliver Wendel Holmes wrote, that a state properly may punish a defendant for acts committed outside the state if those acts were intended to, and actually did, produce detrimental effects within the state.
Personal Jurisdiction in Civil Cases?
Establishing personal jurisdiction in civil cases requires that the court serve the defendant with a summons (or otherwise provide sufficient legal notice of the proceeding), also known as service of process.
A summons, along with the complaint, gives a defendant legal notice of the allegations against her and directs her to appear before the court on a given date.
The legal requirements for serving a summons on someone differ between state and federal courts and are discussed below.
- Relevant Law: International Shoe v Washington, 326 US 310 (1945), requiring minimum contacts with a state, sufficient not to offend notions of fair play and substantial justice.
In a criminal case, personal jurisdiction is generally not an issue.
An individual would assert a defense to the alleged crime rather than assert a lack of personal jurisdiction.
In a civil case, however, personal jurisdiction is a hotly debated topic.
This is particularly true for businesses that place products into the market for sale.
There is a great deal of uncertainty as to what amount of sales activity in a state will subject the business to personal jurisdiction in that state’s courts.
Related Topics
- US Courts (Intro)
- What is the Authority for Article III Courts?
- What is the Authority for Article I Courts?
- What is the authority for courts under Article II?
- What is the authority for Article IV Territorial Courts?
- What is the authority for State Courts?
- What are Article III Courts?
- What are Article I Administrative Courts?
- What are Article IV Territorial Courts?
- What are state courts?
- What is Subject-Matter Jurisdiction?
- What is Federal Court Subject-Matter Jurisdiction?
- What is State Court Subject-Matter Jurisdiction?
- Can a Federal trial courts hear state matters & vice versa?
- Can a Federal appellate court hear federal matters & vice versa?
- What is Personal Jurisdiction?
- How to establish Federal Court Personal Jurisdiction?
- How to establish State Court Personal Jurisdiction?
- What is a Long-Arm Statute?
- Who are the primary players in the state judicial system?
- What types of judges are part of the judiciary?
- What are the duties of trial judges in the legal system?
- Contempt of Court
- Declaratory Judgment
- Equitable Relief
- Equity – Definition
- What are the duties of Appellate Judges & Justices?
- De Novo Review
- What is the role of jurors in the judicial system?
- What number of jurors and juror votes are required for guilt or liability?
- What do Attorneys do?
- Who are the other players in the judicial system?
- US Circuit Court?
- US Supreme Court?
- Appeals from Legislative and Administrative Courts
- Appeals in the state court system?